Written by Brian McGrath
For high-net-worth investors and family offices, Private Placement Variable Annuities (PPVA) and Private Placement Life Insurance (PPLI) are two financial tools that may be considered as a part of a broader wealth planning strategy. Both offer customizable investment frameworks and potential tax-related features, but each has distinct characteristics, considerations, and planning applications that may align differently depending on a client’s objectives, circumstances, and needs.
In this article, I’ll break down the key features of each structure, and the factors advisors and their clients may weigh when evaluating them.
What are the similarities between PPVA and PPLI?
Both PPLI and PPVA may allow for tax-deferral on investment gains generated within the policy. Both structures reduce the administrative complexity often associated with direct alternative investments, as the policy owner generally does not receive K-1s for assets held within an insurance policy, they are received by the insurance carrier. The range of available investment strategies is generally similar across PPLI and PPVA structures, although availability may vary by carrier, product design, and jurisdiction. Both solutions are typically designed for sophisticated wealth planning, requiring investors to meet Accredited Investor and/or Qualified Purchaser thresholds.
PPVA vs PPLI Compared
PPVA | PPLI | |
|---|---|---|
Eligibility requirement | Accredited Investors and Qualified Purchasers Only | Accredited Investors and Qualified Purchasers Only |
Account structure | Assets held in insurer’s separate account, generally insulate claims of the insurer’s creditors. | Assets held in insurer’s separate account, generally insulate claims of the insurer’s creditors. |
Annual K-1 reporting | Not issued to the policy owner, but to the insurance carrier. | Not issued to the policy owner, but to the insurance carrier. |
Surrender charges | Carrier dependent | Carrier dependent |
Investment access
| VITs, IDFs, and SMAs, subject to diversification and investor control rules. | VITs, IDFs, and SMAs, subject to diversification and investor control rules. |
Ability to fund via 1035 exchange
| Yes. May be funded through an exchange of a life policy or an annuity. | Yes. May be funded as an exchange of a life policy only. |
Common planning considerations | • Clients seeking to potentially improve the after-tax returns on tax-inefficient investment strategies.
• Clients with philanthropic intent, as deferred gains generally are not subject to income tax when a charity or other tax-exempt organization is the beneficiary. • Clients who have maximized their PPLI exposure and/or may not qualify for life insurance underwriting. | • Clients focused on multi-generational legacy planning, where death benefit proceeds generally may be received income tax-free and, if properly structured, may be excluded from the taxable estate.
• Clients seeking to improve the tax efficiency of their investment portfolio while also providing a death benefit for future generations. |
While both structures share certain features, they are designed with different considerations and planning objectives in mind. Understanding their key distinctions can help inform discussions about which approach may be appropriate based on a client’s individual circumstances and goals.
What’s the difference between PPVA and PPLI?
The primary distinction between Private Placement Variable Annuities (PPVA) and Private Placement Life Insurance (PPLI) lies in their structure. PPVA is an annuity contract, while PPLI is a life insurance policy.
Because PPLI includes an insured life and a death benefit, it generally requires medical and financial underwriting. PPVA, by contrast, does not provide a life insurance death benefit and therefore typically does not involve underwriting of an insured individual. As a result, the implementation process may differ between the two structures. PPLI’s life insurance component may provide additional planning considerations. Subject to applicable law and proper structuring, death benefit proceeds may be received income tax-free by beneficiaries and, in certain circumstances, may also be excluded from the insured’s taxable estate.
While there is no death benefit in a PPVA contract, earnings generally grow tax deferred until distributed. If a charity or other tax-exempt organization is named as beneficiary, the deferred gain generally is not subject to income tax, and the contract value may qualify for an estate tax charitable deduction.
PPVA | PPLI | |
|---|---|---|
Medical underwriting | Not required | Required |
Withdrawals | Subject to liquidity restrictions of underlying funds and/or managers.
Withdrawals are taxed to the extent of gains on the contract (income-first) as ordinary income and a 10% additional tax generally applies to withdrawals taken before age 59 ½. | Subject to liquidity restrictions of underlying funds and/or managers.
Withdrawals may be taken out of basis first. Then, to the extent the withdrawals exceed basis, the gain may be taxed as ordinary income. Special rules apply to certain policies heavily funded in early policy years in which case withdrawals may be taxed similarly to annuity withdrawals. These life policies are referred to as modified endowment contracts or MECs. |
Death benefit
| Account value passes to a named beneficiary; if paid to a charity or other tax-exempt entity, deferred gains generally are not subject to income tax; otherwise, basis is not stepped up on the date of death and gains above basis are taxed as ordinary income. | Level and/or increasing death benefit generally passes income tax-free to named beneficiaries, subject to applicable tax law. |
When Might a Private Placement Variable Annuity Be Considered?
Every client’s situation is different, and product selection and planning should always be evaluated with a qualified advisor.
For some investors, a PPVA may be considered as part of a broader wealth planning strategy, particularly when there is a desire to hold tax-inefficient investment strategies within an insurance-based structure that does not include a life insurance death benefit. Unlike PPLI, a PPVA generally does not require medical underwriting, which may simplify the implementation process for certain eligible investors while still providing many of the structural features associated with private placement insurance solutions.
A client’s overall planning objectives may also influence the evaluation of a PPVA. In some circumstances, PPVAs can be incorporated into charitable planning strategies. Subject to contract terms and applicable tax laws, some or all of the contract value may be directed to one or more charitable organizations at the owner’s death, which may result in favorable tax treatment. For clients with existing philanthropic goals or charitable giving objectives, a PPVA may be one of several structures considered as part of the broader planning discussion.
For some investors, the simplicity of a PPVA structure compared to PPLI may be an important consideration when evaluating private placement insurance solutions. In addition, PPVAs are not subject to the same life insurance funding considerations that apply to PPLI policies. As a result, PPVAs may provide greater flexibility with respect to the timing and amount of contributions, subject to contract terms, carrier requirements, and applicable regulations.
When Might Private Placement Life Insurance Be Considered?
PPLI may offer planning opportunities that combine potential income tax benefits associated with life insurance death proceeds with broader estate planning strategies. When a properly structured irrevocable trust owns the policy, the death benefit generally may be excluded from the insured’s taxable estate, and death benefit proceeds generally are received income tax-free by beneficiaries. For clients where estate planning is the priority, this combination may be an important consideration.
PPLI is often evaluated in the context of wealth transfer, estate planning, and legacy planning objectives. The life insurance death benefit may provide a tax-efficient means of transferring wealth to beneficiaries.
Depending on how the policy is structured, PPLI owned by a properly structured trust may allow the grantor to leverage his or her Generation-Skipping Transfer (GST) tax exemption, since exemption is allocated to the premiums gifted to the trust rather than to the ultimate death benefit. For families thinking two or three generations ahead, this may make PPLI an important consideration in multi-generational trust planning.
Can PPVA and PPLI Be Used Together?
The choice doesn’t have to be one or the other: it is possible to own both PPVA and PPLI in a portfolio. For ultra-high-net-worth clients and family offices, the two structures may complement each other in support of long-term wealth planning goals.
- PPVA may be considered for investment strategies that generate a significant portion of their return as ordinary income, particularly where tax deferral and investment flexibility are among the primary considerations. Depending on an investor’s objectives, a PPVA may also be incorporated into broader wealth transfer or charitable planning strategies.
- PPLI may be evaluated in situations where wealth transfer, estate planning, or legacy planning considerations are an important part of the overall strategy. The policy’s life insurance death benefit may provide additional planning opportunities.
- In some cases, investors may allocate assets across both PPVA and PPLI based on their broader planning objectives, liquidity needs, time horizon, and estate planning considerations.
Conclusion
Both Private Placement Variable Annuities (PPVA) and Private Placement Life Insurance (PPLI) are insurance-based structures that may be considered by high-net-worth individuals, family offices, and their advisors as part of a broader wealth planning strategy. While the two structures share certain characteristics, including the potential for tax-deferred growth and access to a range of investment strategies, each has distinct features, considerations, and planning applications.
PPVA may be considered by investors seeking an insurance-based structure that supports tax-deferred wealth accumulation without a life insurance death benefit. It may also be incorporated into charitable planning strategies, depending on an investor’s goals and circumstances.
Meanwhile, PPLI combines an investment component with a life insurance death benefit, which may create additional estate, legacy, and wealth transfer planning opportunities. Subject to applicable law and proper structuring, PPLI may offer planning benefits related to the transfer of wealth across generations.
This material is provided for general educational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security or insurance product. PPVA and PPLI are available only to eligible investors who are accredited investors and/or qualified purchasers, as defined under applicable securities law, and are offered through properly licensed financial professionals. PPVA and PPLI investment options are subject to market risk, including possible loss of principal. Availability and permissible investment strategies are subject to carrier, regulatory, and offering requirements.
The tax discussion is limited to general U.S. federal tax principles. State and local and non-U.S. tax treatment may differ. The material is not intended as tax advice. Please consult your own tax advisor regarding your planning needs. Private placement variable annuities and variable life products are offered only pursuant to applicable offering documents and to investors who meet specific eligibility requirements Investment options are subject to market risk, including possible loss of principal.